Sign In
List Your Property
Articles by HomeFinder
Mortgage
This Home!
Sign In
For Sale
: 33
Foreclosures
: 20
Rentals
: 20
Rent To Own
: 20
List
Map
Rentals
NY
Shelter Island
Shelter Island, NY Homes For Rent
Price (low to high)
Price (high to low)
Newest Listings First
Beds
Baths
Year Built
Square Feet
Filter
Sort
Veterans: See if you meet the requirements for a $0 down VA Home Loan. Prequalify today.
1136 Bay Street,
Shelter Island, NY 10305
$2,000 /mo
Rental
1,400 Sqft
15 Montclair Avenue,
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$75,000 /mo
House For Rent
6 Bd | 5 Bath | 4,600 Sqft
21 Peconic AVenue,
Shelter Island, NY 11964
$50,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 2 Bath | 1,691 Sqft
9 Blue Heron Way,
North Haven, NY 11963
$70,000 /mo
Rental
5 Bd | 7 Bath
100 Redwood Road,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$59,500 /mo
House For Rent
4 Bd | 4 Bath | 2,700 Sqft
Middle Line,
SAG HARBOR, NY 11963
$46,657 /mo
Rent to Own
8 Bd | 10 Bath | 8,635 Sqft
46 Bayview Avenue,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$25,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 2 Bath | 10,890 Sqft
Front,
GREENPORT, NY 11944
$11,673 /mo
Rent to Own
51 Hampton Street,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$120,000 /mo
Rental
4 Bd | 2 Bath
6 Maple Street,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$14,000 /mo
House For Rent
2 Bd | 1 Bath
162 Noyack Avenue,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$65,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 3 Bath | 2,596 Sqft
5 Oak Road,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$38,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 2 Bath | 1,220 Sqft
165 Marine Place,
Greenport, NY 11944
$85,000 /mo
Rental
4 Bd | 5 Bath | 3,800 Sqft
81 Pine Neck Avenue,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$17,000 /mo
Rental
2 Bd | 1 Bath | 1,066 Sqft
220 Fiddler Lane,
Greenport, NY 11944
$3,500 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 1 Bath
446 6th Street,
Greenport, NY 11944
$5,000 /mo
House For Rent
4 Bd | 2 Bath | 1,400 Sqft
513 5th Street,
Greenport, NY 11944
$2,600 /mo
Rental
1 Bd | 1 Bath
1935 Old Orchard Road,
East Marion, NY 11939
$6,000 /mo
House For Rent
2 Bd | 1 Bath
33 Oakland Avenue,
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$35,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 3 Bath | 1,670 Sqft
165 Sterling Street,
Greenport, NY 11944
$15,000 /mo
House For Rent
3 Bd | 2 Bath | 1,700 Sqft
Cities Near Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Heights, NY Homes for Rent
Greenport, NY Homes for Rent
Sag Harbor, NY Homes for Rent
Sterling, NY Homes for Rent
East Marion, NY Homes for Rent
Southold, NY Homes for Rent
Wainscott, NY Homes for Rent
Peconic, NY Homes for Rent
Bridgehampton, NY Homes for Rent
Deerfield, NY Homes for Rent
Neighborhoods in Shelter Island, NY
Silver Beach Homes for Rent
Zip Codes in Shelter Island, NY
11964 Homes for Rent
Resource Center
Mortgage
See How Much You Can Afford
Veterans
Veterans: See how much you can save with a VA Loan
